Pages: [1]
Author Topic: Prop Competition?  (Read 133 times)
0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
gogal
Kitsune
Administrator
Junior Otaku
*
Offline Offline

Posts: 229



View Profile
« on: July 12, 2010, 10:16:18 AM »

I'm curious as to why the cosplayers didn't participate more in the prop competition?

The prizes for the show were killer.

What could we do to make it better?
Logged

President
Tekkoshocon Inc.
---
Event Chair
Sangawa Project

greatpein
Junior Otaku

Offline Offline

Posts: 192


this would be the part where you fall down


View Profile WWW
« Reply #1 on: July 12, 2010, 02:37:34 PM »

i never knew where or when the judging was. i wanted to enter but i never found out how. i would explode if you did it again.
Logged

KuroKiiro 2010-
Friday - Gilbert Nightray
Saturday - Sasuke Uchiha
Sunday - Gakuen Sasuke

Omega_gamer_89
Otaku

Offline Offline

Posts: 418


OVER 9000!!!

purplespottedpandas
View Profile WWW Email
« Reply #2 on: July 12, 2010, 05:26:58 PM »

I agree. It was simply under-promoted. I was aware that it existed, but I never knew or found out where in the con it was, when it was, etc... I think that you need to do it again, but promote the competition as a whole much more and then make sure the details are VERY clear whenever someone asks or sees it being promoted. I know that a lot of people didnt know it existed at all, and that many of the people who DID know about it didnt know the details at all.
I wanted to enter, but I never figured out all the info, so I never got around to making my entry prop.

Its definitely a good idea, and you should DEFINITELY do it again. You just need to make sure it gets proper exposure.
Logged

So what if I talk to myself? It's the only way I can have an intelligent conversation anymore.
Our Pittsburgh cosplay group! YOU WILL BE ASSIMILATED!
http://www.facebook.com/#!/group.php?gid=127652917269081&v=wall&ref=ts
AHHH!! RUN!! ITS A BLOG ABOUT THINGS!!!
http://thoughtsaboutthethoughtless.

Patches
Administrator
Otaku
*
Offline Offline

Posts: 393


cosuprei iz srs bsns

padfootpatches
View Profile Email
« Reply #3 on: July 12, 2010, 07:32:24 PM »

I think the main problem is that people didn't want to have to leave their prop there for a good chunk of the weekend to have it displayed and then judged.  Many assumed it would be like the Hall Cosplay where you just go, have it judged and then can leave with it.
Logged


Vice Event Chair - Sangawa-Project 2010
Head of Cosplay- Tekkoshocon VII - IX
Sangawa Project Facebook

gogal
Kitsune
Administrator
Junior Otaku
*
Offline Offline

Posts: 229



View Profile
« Reply #4 on: July 13, 2010, 06:56:42 AM »

I think the main problem is that people didn't want to have to leave their prop there for a good chunk of the weekend to have it displayed and then judged.  Many assumed it would be like the Hall Cosplay where you just go, have it judged and then can leave with it.

So far I've heard that:
1) People didn't know where it was
2) People didn't know how to enter.
3) People were afraid to leave their stuff to be judged
4) Wasn't in Art Show so people didn't really care to be there.
5) People wanted to sell their prop/model.


So, what if the model comp and prop judging happened on one day, where people just dropped off on Saturday before noon and had to pick it up by 3PM on Saturday in the Art Show room?  That way they had their prop and/or model all weekend.
Logged

President
Tekkoshocon Inc.
---
Event Chair
Sangawa Project

greatpein
Junior Otaku

Offline Offline

Posts: 192


this would be the part where you fall down


View Profile WWW
« Reply #5 on: July 13, 2010, 09:18:53 AM »

I think the main problem is that people didn't want to have to leave their prop there for a good chunk of the weekend to have it displayed and then judged.  Many assumed it would be like the Hall Cosplay where you just go, have it judged and then can leave with it.

So far I've heard that:
1) People didn't know where it was
2) People didn't know how to enter.
3) People were afraid to leave their stuff to be judged
4) Wasn't in Art Show so people didn't really care to be there.
5) People wanted to sell their prop/model.


So, what if the model comp and prop judging happened on one day, where people just dropped off on Saturday before noon and had to pick it up by 3PM on Saturday in the Art Show room?  That way they had their prop and/or model all weekend.
while i don't feel comfortable leaving my prop to begin with, only leaving it for a few hours would be MUCH better. another thing is that most of the props probably go with a cosplay so cosplayers would want to have them for their cosplay.
Logged

KuroKiiro 2010-
Friday - Gilbert Nightray
Saturday - Sasuke Uchiha
Sunday - Gakuen Sasuke

gogal
Kitsune
Administrator
Junior Otaku
*
Offline Offline

Posts: 229



View Profile
« Reply #6 on: July 13, 2010, 09:40:35 AM »

while i don't feel comfortable leaving my prop to begin with, only leaving it for a few hours would be MUCH better. another thing is that most of the props probably go with a cosplay so cosplayers would want to have them for their cosplay.

The idea was that you would show off props that may or may not be for the cosplay you did for the show. 
The prop contest was/is different as the prop is judged on its own merrits outside of the costume it is associated with, and by removing the person who built the prop's identity it adds a level judging annonimity.  Think of it, you submit a prop for judging and no one knows who's prop it is.  It is just a number, no name to be filled in.  So, you could be competing against "Super Famous Cosplayer X" but you wouldn't know it absolutly.  Thus a reputation is no longer a factor.

The other idea was to supply a safe place to display the props.  Realistically, when you do the comparison between modelers and cosplayers they both are very protective of their work.  Actually, at times I'll say the high end modelers are may be more protective.  No offence to cosplayers.  Most props aren't extremely fragile that can break with the slightest movement.

It was funny, that cosplayers this year could submit a prop up until noon Saturday to display for judging.  Again, that goes back to the "I didn't know about it" we all discussed earlier.

But, we have now covered that the display for judging time is an issue for props.
Logged

President
Tekkoshocon Inc.
---
Event Chair
Sangawa Project

Pages: [1]
Print
 
Jump to: